It took me eight-hour flight to London to convince me that this past year wasn’t a complete musical wash. It wasn’t that nothing good came out. It’s just that I couldn’t remember. It wasn’t until I stopped to think about it that it hit me: 2018 saw a plethora of releases. Lupe Fiasco dropped Drogas Wave, J. Cole K.O.D., Jorja Smith Lost & Found, Janelle Monae Dirty Computer just to name a few. It was a year of doubling down, triumphant returns, mild letdowns, and stunning debuts. In that sense, it’s a year like any other.
Similar to last year, I want to share some of my favorite listens from this past year. I do this with a bit more humility than my reading list. As mentioned in my book post, my music listening was largely hampered by using my spare time to listen to audiobooks instead. Even so, I kept coming back to these albums:
- The 1975 – A Brief Inquiry into Online Relationships
Just to be clear, I didn’t dislike I Like it When You Sleep, per se. It just didn’t quite reach the greatness of their debut. Though it was a whopping seventeen songs and 74 minutes long, it felt sparse regarding content. They doubled down on their interludes and instead of making them one or two minutes here and there, they were four to five minutes long with multiple back to back. Where their debut possessed energy, their sophomore effort carried sentiment. But still, they were growing into themselves. If I Like It When You Sleep was them realizing they had something to say A Brief Inquiry is them learning how to say it. This album is a perfect synthesis of their two previous albums while exploring new territory. There’s everything from jazz to pop here, making The 1975 one of the most exciting bands to listen to at the moment. Whenever I listen to “How to Draw/Petrichor” I can’t help but think of what a beautiful record this is. If they can replicate the same magic next year with Notes on a Conditional Form, I will absolutely lose my mind.
- The Story So Far – Proper Dose
First thought whenever I listen to this record: They’re baaaack.
What gets me about this record is that, similar to I The Mighty’s Where The Mind Wants to Go/Where You Let It Go, I was ambivalent when I heard the singles. After their self-titled album, which wasn’t bad as much as it was lifeless, I had no idea what to expect. But this album is incredible. Sonically, it combines their old spunk with their new maturity. Of all their records, it’s probably the one I can most easily differentiate one song from another, which makes it a joy to listen to. They got some of their bite back. I’m even willing to forgive Parker’s tendency to over-rhyme things. Like The 1975’s A Brief Inquiry, this album also addresses substance abuse.
- Alkaline Trio – Is This Thing Cursed?
I don’t think I realized how much I missed this band until this album came out. As much as it excited me to see Skiba playing with Blink-182, this is his zone of genius. This album is great not so much because of the lack of greatness on their previous record as much as the length of silence between the two. It’d been five years since they released anything. What I love about this record is that instead of sounding like a modernized version of The Ramones, the Trio sound like themselves again and, man, do they sound good.
- LANY – Malibu Nights
If you know me, you know I’m a sucker for a good story, especially if that good story leads to a good album. Malibu Nights is one of those albums. Released a year after their debut, frontman Paul Jason Klein wrote this album to help him process his breakup. It’s the five stages of grief in musical form. Beck had Sea Change, The Gaslight Anthem had Get Hurt, LANY has Malibu Nights. If you’re looking for something for your broken heart, here you are.
The five stages, if you’re interested (this is all conjecture by the way):
“Thick and Thin” – Denial
“Run,” “I Don’t Want to Love You Anymore” – Anger
“Taking Me Back”, “If You See Her,” “Let Me Know” – Bargaining
“Valentine’s Day,” “Malibu Nights” – Depression
“Thru These Tears” – Acceptance
- Matt Nathanson – Sings His Sad Heart
After a string of what seemed to be perfect albums (Beneath These Fireworks, Some Mad Hope, and Modern Love), Matt Nathanson released some missteps. Even though Last of the Great Pretenders grew on me, it wasn’t my favorite. Show Me Your Fangs was better on first listen but still, when I sat down to think about the tracklist, it was a bit hit or miss. Sings His Sad Heart, though. This album caught me completely off guard. Like Proper Dose, I didn’t really care for the singles. To be honest, they made me afraid to listen to the album. Yet from the moment the beat kicked in on “Mine” I understood what he was going for and I was all for it. It’s probably the most cohesive record he’s released in a while. Though I get what some critics have said about the lack of depth, still, great record.
Honorable Mention:
- Coheed & Cambria – Vaxis, Act I: The Unheavenly Creatures
If other singles had me scared for an album, this album had me so scared I didn’t even listen to the singles. And yet, here we are. Dare I say the best album they’ve released in a decade? In some ways, it’s Coheed being Coheed and, because of that, you’re tempted to write it off. But when you realize that Coheed hasn’t exactly been the Armory Wars Coheed for the last ten years, you begin to appreciate the density of this record. Sonically, it’s an amalgamation of all their work thus far (“Love Protocol” could’ve been on Color Before the Sun, “The Dark Sentencer” could’ve been on Afterman: Ascension, etc.). After taking a break from concept albums, they come back here in full force. It doesn’t feel like Claudio was living his life and then tried to fit a concept in it. It sounds like he actually sat down to write out a story and it’s all here.
One last note:
The Letdowns
Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness– Upside Down Flowers
When a guy who’s been in the habit of releasing an album every three years releases two albums within two years, that means it’s either really good or really rushed. I never thought I’d say this about anything Andrew McMahon has released, but this is probably the first album he’s released I’m not crazy about. Even Jack’s Mannequin’s People & Things was, at the very least, a collection of good songs. Upside Down Flowers is just plain lackluster. It’s what Andrew McMahon when he’s got nothing to lose or to prove and just messing around in his garage. What made Zombies on Broadway so brilliant was the overall story it told, it reached a climactic moment that kicked us into the resolution. The songs were energetic and catchy. It sounded like a bustling life in New York. Even the self-titled album sounded like laidback Southern California. This album is none of the above. It’s nostalgic and intentionally not catchy (in that way it picks up where “Birthday Song” left off). It borders on dad-rock. Of the eleven songs on this album, there are maybe three I genuinely hope he plays live. The most generous I can be with this album is that it’s not that bad if you’re in the mood to listen to it. Perhaps, it’s best to see this album as a bonus? His Paradise Valley, the album you weren’t supposed to get.
Fickle Friends – You Are Someone Else
This was a surprising letdown. If you’ve asked me who I’ve been jamming out to for the last year or two, I would’ve mentioned Fickle Friends. I was so excited for their debut, and it just didn’t match up. The problem is that it’s almost like a compilation of some of their best songs with some new ones thrown in that don’t carry their weight. It’s uneven, lacks cohesion, and if I’m honest, I miss older Fickle Friends.